Skip to main content

Forsaken Virtues in Community Management - Part II


Just was made aware that my video, the censoring of it on the official forums, me leaving those forums and the aftermath of it resulting in a couple of other people leaving, has sparked interest of the #1 German speaking PC Gaming Magazine. Here is my rough translation of the original article. The German original is linked here.



 
Shroud of the Avatar: Forsaken Virtues: Doomsday in the forum

Die Geduld der Fans von Shroud of the Avatar scheint am Ende zu sein. (2) 

Richard "Lord British" Garriotts upcoming RPG Shroud of the Avatar has had trouble from the beginning.

Reason for that was, that it was praised as the ULTIMATE RPG for RPG fans with epic singleplayer part and an online world in memory of Ultima Online.

But somehow the game fails to achieve both of those things yet, and this in spite of announcing its release initially for late 2014 and now delayed to the middle or end of 2017. The issue that is does not play like a new Ultima Online and also has no epic singleplayer experience with interesting quests or decisions with consequences, has been a strain on peoples patience for too long. Their discontent vented in the past days in the offcial forum. Several thread containing in parts very harsh critique of the game were posted. The game would only appeal to people with a large wallet, to buy houses, player towns and decorations for real money.

Essential game elements like the unbalanced combat, meaningless PVP system and the basically non existent single player mode, with boring and loveless quests are not making much progress. Most critique of this would be defended against from "White Knights", that defend every decision of the Developers and choke any discussion of the critique, additionally there would be censorship and deleted threads repeatedly.

The developers don't take the critique seriously, that is also mentioned outside of the forums, for example Reddit, and reviews of the Steam Early Access version of Shroud of the Avatar. Those reviews are in parts devastating.

Because of that some diehard fans of the game decided to take their leave from the game and the community.

Up to this point there has been no reaction from the developers to that issue. A short time ago Richard Garriott mentioned in an interview with Polygon, that he has the opinion, the fans are happy and are behind the game. Apparently this seems to have changed...


End of the article...

So what now?

Some of you might think I pitched that article but you have to take my word on it I didn't.


However I knew this was going to happen sooner or later. I hope we can get back to a common ground again concerning the community guidelines and make some changes to them...It is necessary.

I can only speak for myself that I am willing to reach out... will you Portalarium?
;)


 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Banned again for hurting a Dev's feelings...

Apparently contradicting a developer is now a bannable offense. Especially if it is factual and he can't come up with a rebuttal. ;)

Rick Holtrop wrote me a letter again that I was banned for being combative and contradicting a developer. So cute, as this has never been a violation according to their community guidelines.

Next up he fails to elaborate on how it is combative to tell someone who was apologizing for mentioning the Master of the Forge charity, that he doesn't need to apologize as his post didn't violate any rules. Which it didn't since mentioning or questioning the charity wasn't yet forbidden either, before Darkstarr needed to threaten people with warnings if they mention the charity.

I guess most of us just have to take a look at some of the Dev's Twitter or other social media accounts to get a clue where this behavior is coming from. Some of them became pure left wing collectivist. There is hardly a difference between a National Socialist or a …

SotA Release and Q2 Outlook...

As someone who has over 5000 hours into SotA testing it, I must say the game releases with a solid foundation to build on... Even though it obviously still is managed by people who not only seem to have zero connection to gamers nowadays, but also to common sense.

But let's stay on the game. The last Releases clearly shifted the game towards a more group-oriented gameplay. Not only self sufficiency is likely to go away, grouping for the first time feels worth it and actually can yield better results pretty early in the game and even later - depending on your builds.

Coming with that I am glad to see finally Portalarium realizes that their lack of "repeatable" content aka endgame content is something they need to solve within the first 3 months of release. Combining that with the promised Castle Siege mechanics, that can and likely will be used to improve Control Points as well is a step towards generating conflicts and a major driver for people to get engaged.


With Travi…

Archery needs love. What Chris needs to do...

Long time no post...


But boy SotA hasn't been boring. PK action picked up quite a bit with increasing player numbers post release, and flattened a little bit with the latest decrease in player numbers. But I can say I never made more money PKing, especially with the newer bounty ruleset. Pushed 3 Videos in 2 Releases so far... Good times.

Interesting enough some of the old guilds came back and some new transitioned over from Mortal Online.. however the older ones seem to be turning their backs again right away, after seeing they cannot get a foot into PVP anymore.
Which is sad, SotA desperatedly needs to give options for low level and casual oriented Players that maybe don't want to risk the ransom when playing alone, but maybe take part in more structured conflict in a group, where the risk of losing is smaller and can be mitigated.
Right now everyone has to compete with the best, and that leads to a lot of frustration for casuals or returning players. Factions...

But let&#…